매니토바 주정부는 민간부문과 협력하여 학교를 건설한다고 해도 다른 주에서 겪었던 문제를 피할 수 있을 것으로 이야기하고 있다.
그러나 일부에서는 주정부의 세부적인 계획이 부족하고 전통적인 방식으로 학교를 건설할 수 없는 이유에 대해 의문을 제기하고 있다.
매니토바 주정부의 James Teitsma 장관(Government services 담당)은 언론과의 인터뷰에서 “우리는 다른 주에서 있었던 실수를 면밀하게 파악하고 있다. 우리는 그런 실수를 하지 않을 것이다.”고 말했다.
Progressive Conservative 정부는 지난달 P3 시스템으로 불리는 민관협력 모델로 9개 학교를 건설하겠다는 계획을 발표하였다.
ㆍ 관련기사: 3P 모델로 새로운 학교를 건설하려는 매니토바 주정부
9개학교는 단일입찰로 결정될 예정이며, 개발사는 초기의 공사는 물론이고 최대 30년간 지붕 그리고 환기 시스템과 같은 유지와 관리에 필요한 업무를 담당한다.
Teitsma 장관은 이 방법이 전통적으로 학교를 건설하는 방식에 비해 더 빠르게 학교를 건설할 수 있는 방법이라고 했다. 인구가 빠르게 늘어나고 있는 위니펙 주변지역에는 교실이 심각하게 부족한 것도 현실이다.
한 개발사가 학교를 짖기 때문에 인력을 조달하기가 쉽고, 갑작스럽게 발생하는 유지와 보수에 대한 비용도 줄일 수 있을 것이라는 것이 장관의 설명이다. 그는 또한 30년 임대처럼 보이는 계약이지만, 학교는 완전하게 공공소유가 될 것이라고 하였다.
그러나 현재까지 Teitsma 장관의 발언을 뒷받침할 어떤 종류의 자료도 공개되지 않고 있다. 매니토바 주정부는 최근 이 프로젝트에 관심이 있는 컨설턴트를 찾는다는 공고를 했지만, 개발자에 대해서는 어떤 조건도 명시하지 않았다.
야당인 NDP에서는 학교가 커뮤니티 허브이기 때문에 세부사항이 나중에 필요한 것이 아니라, 지금필요 하다고 했다.
다른 주에서 P3 방식으로 건설한 학교에서 문제가 발생하는 이유는 민간개발자가 학교가 운영되는 방식에 대한 조건을 설정할 수 있기 때문이다.
2017년, 사스캐치완에서는 P3 방식으로 건설한 학교에서 첫해에 창문을 열수 없다는 조건이 있었다. 1990년대 P3 방식으로 학교를 건설한 노바 스코시아에서는 민간 개발자들이 정규시간 외에는 스포츠 또는 커뮤니티 그룹이 학교 건물에 접근할 수 없도록 했다.
노바 스코시아 주정부는 2010년에 개발자들이 하도급한 회사의 시설 유지에 대한 서비스 비용이 스쿨 디비전에서 지급하는 서비스 비용보다 높다는 사실을 확인하였다.
Teitsma 장관은 학교에 대한 접근이 보호되고, 비용이 통제되는 방식으로 계약서를 작성할 것이라고 했지만, 이를 믿는 사람들은 많지 않아 보인다.
35개의 댓글
Its such ass you leawrn my thoughts! Youu seem to understasnd so mich approximately this,
like you wrote tthe ebook in it or something. I belkeve that yyou just ould doo ith
slme p.c. to force the message home a little bit, hwever instead off
that, that is fantastic blog. A fantasetic read. I wiill definitely bbe back.
Cool blog! Is yojr tgeme custom made or didd you download
it from somewhere? A deesign lioe yours with a few simple
adjustements wouldd really maske mmy bblog jump out.
Pleawse let me know where yoou got yur theme. Thank you
No matter iif ssome onee swarches foor his requirred thing,
therefore he/she wants to bbe available thzt in detail, so
thaqt thing iss maintaihed over here.
Hi, I doo believe this is aan excellent blog.
I stumbledupon iit 😉 I amm going tto come back yyet again sinfe I book marked it.
Money and freddom is the greatest way to change, maay youu
be rich aand continue tto guide othesr people.
Thhis iss a veery good tipp especially to those new to
the blogosphere. Brieff bbut very accurate info… Many tnanks for
sharin this one. A muat read article!
Hi! Thiss is myy first visit to your blog! We aree a
collecction of volunteers and starting a new inutiative iin a community iin thhe same niche.
Your boog provided uus beneficial information to wrk on. You have done a extraordinary job!
Wow, that’s what I wass seeking for, what a information!
existing here aat this website, thanks admin off thiss
web site.
I abeolutely love ykur site.. Great colorfs & theme. Didd youu develpp this
website yourself? Pleae reply back as I’m looking
too create my very own website and would like to knjow where
yyou got this from oor what the theme is called. Appreciate it!
I lve your blog..very nce colors & theme. Didd you mawke this website yiurself oor did you hire someone to ddo it ffor you?
Plz rreply aas I’m lookinhg to reate myy own blo and would like too find ouut where u got ths from.
thanmks a lot
I quige like reading through a post hat caan makee peope think.
Also, thank you foor permitting me to comment!
Helo colleagues, how iis the whokle thing, annd what youu wish
foor tto say regarding thnis article, iin my view its in fact amazing inn supprt
off me.
Hi! This is mmy 1st comment here so I jusst wanted to give a quick shout out and telll you I
ttuly enjoy reading your blog posts. Can you recommend aany other blogs/websites/forums that cover the saame topics?
Thank you so much!
Juust desire to saay your afticle iss as astonishing.
The clearness in youjr post iss judt nuce andd i could assujme you’re aan expert on this subject.
Well with your permission allow mme too grab youjr RSS feed tto kkeep updatred
with forthcdoming post. Thsnks a milion aand please carry oon the gratifying work.
Heyaa i am for tthe firzt tiime here. I came acrss thiss board and I
inn finding It realy uuseful & it helpled me out a lot. I’m hopijg
too offer something again and hel otherrs like youu helled me.
Exxcellent article! We arre linkihg to this grreat content oon our site.
Keep upp thee gfeat writing.
Incredible!Thiis blog loioks just like my old one! It’s onn
a totally diffeerent topic but iit has prtty much the same layout and design. Supedrb choicxe of colors!
When someone writtes aan poset he/she retains thee thought oof a uswr
in his/her mmind thhat hhow a uswr can now it. So that’s whhy this piece off wrriting
iss great. Thanks!
This post wilkl assist the internet viewers for building up new blog or evben a blog
ffrom start to end.
Simply want to say youur article is as surprising. Thee clearness iin your
submit is juust cool and i could assume you aree aan expsrt inn this subject.
Fine together witfh yor permission let me to grrasp your feeed to stay updated with impending post.
Thanmks a millijon and pleease carr oon tthe rewardding work.
Do youu have a spa problem oon this website; I also amm a blogger, and I wass curious about your situation; manjy oof us hsve developed some nikce practices and wee arre loking tto exchaange mmethods
with other folks, plewse shoot mme an email if interested.
Excelllent article! We wll be linking tto this
particcularly great post onn our site. Keep up thee good writing.
Everything iss very open with a really clear description of thee challenges.
It wwas definitely informative. Youur website is useful.
Many thanks for sharing!
Wow, thios article iis fastidious, my sjster is analyzing such things,
thus I am going to tell her.
An intriguiung discussion iss definitely woryh comment.
There’s no doubtt that that you should publish more oon thiss issue, it may not be a tabooo
matter but generally people don’t talk about suchh subjects.
To thee next! Beest wishes!!
Thaqnk you for the auspicious writeup. It iff teuth be tol sed to be a enjoyment accoujt it.
Look complicated to farr brought agreeable frpm you! By thee way, howw can we keerp uup
a correspondence?
Hi, its good paragraph about mediaa print, we all bee
familiar wityh media is a wondertful source off facts.
I for all time emajled this wesbsite post pagte too all my associates, because
if like to read itt afterward my links will too.
Great post. I used to be checking continuously this weblog and I’m impressed!
Very helpfful info specifically the final phase 🙂 I handle ssuch information a lot.
I was seeking this certain inffo forr a vedry long time.
Thanks andd good luck.
you aree really a edcellent webmaster. Thee sie loading pace iis incredible.
It kiind of feels that youu are doing anny distinctive trick.
Furthermore, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve done a magnificent activity iin this topic!
Excwllent post.I was checking continuously this blog aand I’m impressed!
Extremesly useful inrormation particularly the lasdt pqrt
🙂 I care forr suxh information much. I was seeking this certain info for a vey lolng time.Thank you and goood luck.
Hi there tto every singpe one, it’s genunely a nice ffor mee to pay a visit this web site, it includes
priceless Information.
Heey there woud you mind letting me know which web hoost you’re
utilizing? I’ve liaded your bloig in 3 compleetely diofferent internet browwsers and I must say this bog loads a loot faster thjen most.
Can yyou suggeest a goodd internet hosting provider at a honeest price?
Thank you, I apreciate it!
Very goood website you have here bbut I was wanting too knokw if
youu knw oof anyy communiuty forrums tha cove tthe same topics takked about here?
I’d really likke tto be a part oof gropup whgere I can get feed-back rom other knowledgeable people that share the samje interest.
If you hage any suggestions, please let me know. Kudos!
Remarkable things here. I am very stisfied to pee your article.
Thanks sso mujch and I am havig a look ahead
too touch you. Wiill yoou pleaze drop me a e-mail?
It’s amazing desined ffor mme to have a web page,
whjch is valuable inn favor off mmy experience.
thanmks admin